Việt Nam quickly shutters ‘Land Reform’ exhibit

Show on post-WWII revolutionary land policy causes online outrage and is soon closed.

In Hà Nội this week, a short-lived exhibition at Việt Nam’s National History Museum, Land Reform 1946-57, triggered a national moment to relive a long-ago trauma.

On September 5, the Ministry of Culture, Tourism and Sports website posted an announcement saying that the History Museum would hold an exhibit from September 8 until December assembled from the archives of the central government, the Communist Party and various provincial museums.

It was an exhibit “pregnant with valuable historical contents never shown before,” the ministry said.

Scholars outside Việt Nam and (very quietly) inside the country have debated for 60 years how many landlords ‑ large, small, kind, wicked, pro or anti-Communist — perished in the paroxysm of class warfare that followed France’s expulsion from the northern half of Việt Nam in 1954.

A few Vietnamese who remember that period intimately, notably the economic historian Đặng Phong and, very recently, the journalist Trần Đĩnh, have said openly that the ideologically driven land reform campaign was a complete failure.

For younger generations, however, the gory details ‑ at least 100,000, and perhaps two or three times that many, landlords were shot, beheaded or beaten to death by peasant mobs incited by Party cadres – have been lost from view.

land-refrom-1You had to hurry if you wanted to see the show

The curators at the National History Museum certainly did not intend to arouse doubts about the correct management of affairs long ago.

The exhibit was designed to “educate… especially youth to comprehend more deeply and correctly the agricultural revolution… and strengthen belief and pride in the Party, government and revolutionary achievements of the People.”

They didn’t reckon with the Internet.

As in many other nations, the rowdy online world of news, rumor and rants has hamstrung the regime’s effort to manage public opinion.

News of the exhibit caused a flood of online claims that it whitewashed the past, triggering long repressed accounts of chaos, cruelty and injustice, meted out even to revolutionary heroes like Nguyễn Thị Nam who were, incidentally, also substantial landowners.

Well over a third of Việt Nam’s 90-plus million people regularly go online, mostly to play games and socialize, but also to read stories that don’t get reported by the authorized media.

They read, for example, that these days land is often wrested from farmers to clear the way for industrial, commercial or housing projects, and that the courts are clogged with lawsuits protesting the meager compensation given in exchange.

It was not a big surprise, therefore, that the unprecedented exhibition prompted grandparents to relate miscarriages of justice during the land reform period and their grandchildren to post them on blogs or Facebook accounts.

On the morning of September 9, the third day of the exhibition, a few dozen people, all wearing red shirts proclaiming themselves farmers from the village of Dương Nội and bearing placards demanding “human rights,” marched from a bus station to the History Museum.

They’d come to see the exhibit, they told guards.

land-refrom-2Can we come in? 

The guards had no difficulty, apparently, recognizing the people in the red shirts as farmers who have for two years been protesting the Hà Nộii City Government’s seizure of their land for redevelopment.

“It’s 11 am.”

The guards pointed out.

“We’re closing for lunch until 2 pm.”

At 2 pm, the farmers from Dương Nội were back.

“You’ll have to take off those red shirts.”

The guards told them.

The farmers complied.

The guards conferred again and announced that there was a lighting problem in the museum so the land reform exhibit was temporarily closed.

Inside the building, representatives of the Communist Party’s Propaganda Commission and officials of the Ministry of Culture were talking to museum director Nguyễn Văn Cường.

Presently it was announced that the land reform exhibition would be closed and replaced by an exhibition of antiquities.

Ironically, that same day the BBC’s Vietnamese Service posted an interview with historian Dương Trung Quốc, one of the few non-Communist members of the national legislature, on the significance of the land reform exhibit.

Dr. Quốc was upbeat.

“We need to discuss our mistakes, our failures…

Sixty years have gone by.

If we cling to the notion that all the landlords were evil people who exploited the peasants, while the peasants were all fine people… then our society won’t learn lessons from the past and our young people will just be turned off.”

By DAVID BROWN (*)

(*) David Brown is a former US diplomat with detailed knowledge of Việt Nam

Source: Asia Sentinel

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s